Interview questions
First-Time Manager interview questions
First-Time Manager interview questions for each round: stepping up, leading without a track record, and what each round is scoring.
Answer one First-Time Manager question out loud today and time yourself.
How First-Time Manager interviews are scored
First-time manager interviews score leadership you have already shown without the title. Panels look for times you mentored, ran a project or settled a disagreement, because that is the only evidence they have.
What hiring managers check in First-Time Manager interviews
- Whether you have already led without the title, because that is the only evidence a panel has for a first-time manager.
- Whether you can give direct feedback in the room, which the live feedback task tests.
- Whether you accept doing less of your own work, since new managers who keep the best tasks for themselves stall the team.
Pick the check you are weakest on and prepare one First-Time Manager story for it tonight.
Questions First-Time Manager candidates get
On top of the questions every role in this field is asked, these come up for this title in particular.
Screening interview questions
Usually a recruiter or talent partner, 15 to 30 minutes, often by phone or video.
- Why do you want to move into management now?
- Where have you already led people without having the title?
- Have you acted up or covered for your manager, and for how long?
- What do you expect to be different about your week once you manage people?
Hiring manager interview questions
The person you would report to, 45 to 60 minutes, sometimes with a team member.
- Tell me about a time you helped a colleague improve without being their manager.
- What will be the hardest part of letting go of the work you are good at?
- Tell me about a time you disagreed with a decision and still carried it out.
- How would you lead a team member who is older or more experienced than you?
Final round questions
Senior leaders, a panel, or a case task, 60 minutes to half a day.
- Role-play your first one-to-one with a team member who also applied for this job.
- Give feedback to us now on a piece of work that missed the brief.
- You have 30 minutes with a quiet team member who rarely speaks up: what do you cover?
- Your former peers invite you to Friday drinks to complain about management: what do you do?
Plus the manager questions every round asks
- Walk me through your leadership background in two minutes.
- How many people have you managed, and at what levels?
- What budget or results have you been accountable for?
- Tell me about a team you turned around.
- Tell me about a time you managed someone out.
- How do you set goals for your team and track them?
- What would your first 90 days look like here?
- Our team has low engagement scores: how would you approach it?
- How do you balance hitting targets with looking after your people?
Get the manager question pack by email
Every question on this page in one email, grouped by round. Plus three things that are not on the page:
- 12 more questions, 4 per round, that only go out by email
- What a strong answer covers in each round, to check yourself against
- A 7-day prep plan that matches where you are in your search
Final round
One question, three answers, three scores
The same question answered three ways, scored the way an interviewer would mark it.
“Give feedback to us now on a piece of work that missed the brief.”
“It's really great overall, and there are just a few small things we could maybe tweak if there's time.”
“Thanks for this. It's well written, but it doesn't cover the pricing section in the brief. Can you add that by Friday?”
“The brief asked for three pricing options and this has one, so as it stands it won't answer the client's question. Talk me through how you read the brief, because if I wasn't clear, that's on me. Let's agree what the other two options need, and send me a draft by Thursday so we have a day to review.”
Example scores on the 0 to 100 scale CareersAble uses. Your own answer gets its own score.
Reading the questions is not the same as answering them.
CareersAble writes the questions your actual job ad will ask, records your answers, scores each one three times and tells you plainly what to fix.
Free to start. No card needed.